Trigger Warning: Sexual Assault
Unmasking the Two-Finger Test: Patriarchy and Unconstitutionality
Patriarchy, a central and complex system that upholds gender inequality, impacts how people in positions of authority respond to sexual assault. The ‘two-finger test’ or the ‘per vaginum’ test which has been repeatedly decried and now banned by the Indian Supreme Court (see here) in 2013 is an example of this.
“This court has time and again deprecated the use of two finger test in cases alleging rape and sexual assault. The so-called test has no scientific basis. It instead re-victimizes and re-traumatizes women.”
In India (as well as other parts of the Subcontinent) in addition to other processes, survivors of sexual assault undergo a set of medical tests. A component of this medical process is the unscientific “two-finger test.” This invasive test involves a medical practitioner inserting two fingers into the vagina of a survivor.
This extremely traumatizing practice remains normalized largely because it relies on patriarchal notions like “virginity” or “laxity of the vagina.” These notions are used by medical practitioners and police personnel alike to ‘decide’ whether a survivor has been raped or not.
The term “virginity” is synonymous – at least in our society today – with a woman’s ‘chastity’ and is a determining factor for one’s character. Similarly, the seemingly scientifically named notion of ‘laxity’ relies on the false understanding that vaginas ‘lose laxity’ with repeated penetration. Underpinning this harmful understanding is the patriarchal logic that a person with a ‘loose’ vagina ‘cannot be raped.’
On the contrary, the U.S.-based National Center for Biotechnology Information suggests that the ‘laxity’ of the vagina “may develop after pregnancy and vaginal delivery and may be affected by prior surgery, menopause and aging.” In short, vaginal laxity, a factor on which the two-finger test decides whether an individual is a survivor of rape or not is completely baseless and incorrect.
The test’s persistence also brings to the surface many other patriarchal logics: not believing women, not understanding how survivors are put through trauma again by the very authorities that claim to ‘protect’ them, and treating a survivor as a passive victim with no agency to determine what next steps to take to heal from trauma.
This list is long and so has been the fight to end the practice. Yet, while the test is banned, it continues to be practiced around the country. We at Jhatkaa alongside the National Council for Women Leaders (NCWL) are launching a nation-wide campaign to demand an end to this invasive and baseless practice. Add your sign to this campaign – it will allow us to contact and put pressure on the relevant authorities to take actions on our demands which you can read on the petition page. Join us today by signing now: https://bit.ly/43om5wm
You can also find out more about the campaign on our social media which we update regularly:
8 Comments
बेला जेराई
Hamen milkar is aakramak aur niraadhaar pratha ko samapt karne ke liye mahilaon ko ekjut hona padega .
Sunil Talwar
Is there any data which certifies that only virgins are sexually assaulted or raped. If not Then how does this two finger test helps if a married woman or a sexually active female is assaulted if they too are subjected to this test. This test is outrageous to the dignity of a female and courts should make police or medical practitioner accountable if they conduct this test on a rape survivor.
Abdul Wafa
Stop rapes, educate children and give them better future, keep children away from dirty politics & dirty ideologies of any religion
Divya Gupta
I wish ki Jo Dr is test ki practice karre h vo is pitition ko smjhe or is test ko continue na kare
Tapaswini Barik
The society is at fault here. Our boys need to be nurtured better, our girls need to be empowered. Rape happens as a result of our degraded values and morals, male ego and inequality in terms of gender roles. Anyone can be a rapist. Your best friend, your uncle, your relative. In my opinion creating a strong awareness in school children would be a good start. To stop rape, the general attitude of men towards women needs to change. The objectification of women in tv and movies does not help at all! Also, parents need to be a part of this education. I think children invariably learn how to treat women based on how the mother is treated in the house. Stopping rape itself could be temporarily achieved with more stringent laws. But to truly improve the way women are treated in India, it has to start young.
To my sense our Hon’ble Apex Court has ordered very perfect the ban of the two finger test which is unscientific and against Art. 14 of the Constitution of India also to my sense and inhumane and insulting to the Victim.
Tapaswini Barik
THE SOCIETY IS AT FAULT HERE. OUR BOYS NEED TO BE NURTURED BETTER, OUR GIRLS NEED TO BE EMPOWERED. RAPE HAPPENS AS A RESULT OF OUR DEGRADED VALUES AND MORALS, MALE EGO AND INEQUALITY IN TERMS OF GENDER ROLES. ANYONE CAN BE A RAPIST. YOUR BEST FRIEND, YOUR UNCLE, YOUR RELATIVE. IN MY OPINION CREATING A STRONG AWARENESS IN SCHOOL CHILDREN WOULD BE A GOOD START. TO STOP RAPE, THE GENERAL ATTITUDE OF MEN TOWARDS WOMEN NEEDS TO CHANGE. THE OBJECTIFICATION OF WOMEN IN TV AND MOVIES DOES NOT HELP AT ALL! ALSO, PARENTS NEED TO BE A PART OF THIS EDUCATION. I THINK CHILDREN INVARIABLY LEARN HOW TO TREAT WOMEN BASED ON HOW THE MOTHER IS TREATED IN THE HOUSE. STOPPING RAPE ITSELF COULD BE TEMPORARILY ACHIEVED WITH MORE STRINGENT LAWS. BUT TO TRULY IMPROVE THE WAY WOMEN ARE TREATED IN there own house, IT HAS TO START YOUNG.
TO MY SENSE OUR HON’BLE APEX COURT HAS ORDERED VERY PERFECT THE BAN OF THE TWO FINGER TEST WHICH IS UNSCIENTIFIC AND AGAINST ART. 14 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA ALSO TO MY SENSE AND INHUMANE AND INSULTING TO THE VICTIM.
Sorang Yapa
How can you tell whether a woman is raped or not by just touching. I’m strongly against with the method which is scientifically invalid. #BAND_TWO_TEST
Maneesha
Yes, it needs to be protested vehemently because it is indeed a deep rooted and internalized form of patriarchy which still is practised by our societies.